Clinique Spontini
Under our open methodology this clinic scores 81/100 on structural verification: physician certification, licences, facility and legal-entity traceability, identifier disclosure and advertising honesty.
Rank #4 of 19 ranked clinics · last checked 20 September 2026
No crown: crowns require register-verified gates, never a clinic's own claim.
81/100
coverage 100% (threshold 75%)
Summary
Aesthetic surgery and medicine clinic in Paris 16e. The national facility extract holds an ARS-authorised standalone aesthetic-surgery facility (FINESS category 630) under the legal-entity number the clinic publishes, recorded at a different street number in the same street. The company that held that facility registration is recorded in liquidation in the national companies register; the clinic’s legal notice names its publisher as a trading name without a legal form or a company registration number. The site names two physicians with their national registration numbers.
Google Maps listing (reference, not scored)
What the clinic's public Google Maps listing showed when we read it: the rating other people gave, the number of their reviews and the hours the clinic itself publishes there. This block is a reference only — it does not enter the score, the rank, the ceilings or the holds, and we have not checked it beyond matching the listing to this record.
| Google rating | 5 out of 5 · reviews: 7 |
|---|---|
| Opening hours as published on the listing |
|
| Open the listing on Google Maps | Google Maps |
Source: Google Maps, read 2 October 2026. The listing was matched to this record by the clinic's website address, the clinic's phone number.
Axis by axis
rubric value 1–5 · ? could not verify (no points, not a negative finding) · — not applicable: this country has no register of that class · OFF official register · SEC secondary source
| Axis | Finding (rubric anchor) | Value | Source class | Weight | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| M1 | Specialist certification of the responsible physician Found, status current; the registered specialty matches what this physician advertises. ANS RPPS register: spécialité ordinale SM10 confirmed for the named site physician Dr Edery. [rpps-sf] |
OFF | 26 | 2026-08-31 | |
| M2 | Identifiability of the responsible physician Physician(s) named with role and tied to this address. Clinic site names physicians with role and address, including published RPPS numbers. [site] |
SEC | 16 | 2026-08-31 | |
| M3 | Basic medical licence Matched by the licence number the clinic itself publishes. French medical doctorate (DE05) on record for Dr Edery. [rpps-dipl] |
OFF | 8 | 2026-08-31 | |
| M4 | Facility registration Found with a spelling discrepancy; or the location is registered under the name of the host facility at the same address (a practice inside a hospital or a centre); or the value comes from a mirror or from a directory that shows no status — the profile names the record holder verbatim. The national facility extract holds the record the clinic points to — category 630 (Installation autonome de chirurgie esthétique), legal-entity number 750044257 as published in the site footer, establishment number 750044265, name IACE CLINIQUE SPONTINI PARIS — but its address fields read 68 R SPONTINI B, 75016 PARIS, while the clinic publishes and operates at 76 rue Spontini, 75016 Paris. Name and category match; the street number does not. [finess] |
OFF | 10 | 2026-09-20 | |
| M5 | Legal-entity traceability Only a brand, without a legal form and without a responsible person. Whatever we find ourselves is shown on the profile as a fact and does not raise this cell. The legal notice names the publisher as a trading name with no legal form and no company registration number. The one company number printed on that page belongs, in the national companies register, to the site hosting provider and is given under the hosting heading. [legal-notice] [host-company] |
OFF | 8 | 2026-09-20 | |
| M6 | Self-disclosure of identifiers Physician numbers published; facility or legal-entity numbers not. The site footer publishes the national registration number of each of the two named physicians and the facility number of the clinic, each with its register named; no company registration number of the operator is published. [site] [legal-notice] Dr. Nathanaël Edery – Chirurgien plasticien · RPPS 10102261806 | Clinique Paris Spontini · 76 rue Spontini, 75016 Paris · FINESS 750044257 |
SEC | 10 | 2026-09-20 | |
| M7 | Advertising honesty One or two soft superlatives or non-absolute safety promises. Lexicon scan of 15 pages in French (home, legal notice, team, three aesthetic-medicine pages, privacy policy, reviews, before/after, prices, contact, rhinoplasty, breast reconstruction, melanoma excision, a blog post). Two soft comparative statements in the clinic's own copy; no outcome or safety guarantee. The strongest wording on the site sits in third-party patient reviews reproduced from a review platform, not in the clinic's own text. [site] [rhinoplasty] |
SEC | 12 | 2026-09-20 | |
| M8 | Cross-locale consistency Some facts appear on only one front. Mechanical comparison of 2 language fronts (fr, en) on 2026-09-21: a phone number appears on one front only; number 10102261806 on fr only; number 10101447265 on fr only. [fronts] |
SEC | 5 | 2026-09-21 | |
| M9 | Patient documents Two or three. Pages loaded as listed for M7. Three of the five classes are published: risks and complications of the procedure in a dedicated section, post-operative instructions and follow-up, and secondary revision after tissue stabilisation. A consent document and a complaints route were not found; the site does state that the legal reflection period applies before any aesthetic surgery and that a detailed quotation is issued. [rhinoplasty] [site] |
SEC | 5 | 2026-09-20 |
Score ceilings
No ceiling applies. We never apply one on 'not found' alone.
Holds
Inclusion policy
Four mechanical conditions. The first three decide whether a clinic is listed at all; the fourth decides whether it can be scored.
| Identifiable: live public surface + working in-country contact | verified yes [site] |
|---|---|
| Provides the service itself (not an aggregator, booking site or tour packager) | verified yes [site] |
| In scope: the intervention is performed by a physician | verified yes [site] |
| Names a responsible physician | verified yes [site] |
Who is responsible
Named physicians and the legal entity, as published and as matched in the registers. A missing number is a statement about disclosure, not about licensing.
| Physician | Role | Register ID |
|---|---|---|
| Dr Nathanel Edery [site] [rpps-act] [rpps-sf] | Chirurgien plasticien, spécialité ordinale SM10 | 10102261806 |
| Dr Daniel Alimi [site] | Médecin, médecine esthétique | 10101447265 |
Legal entity: could not verify
Scope and procedure segments
Clinic focus: specialist (no focus adjustment) [site]
What we could not verify
Every applicable axis holds a sourced value.
Contact details
| Website | https://clinique-spontini.fr/ |
|---|---|
| Phone | +33 1 84 74 95 27 |
| Address | 76 bis rue Spontini, 75016 Paris |
| City | Paris |
For identification only; details change — verify with the clinic directly.
Sources
| ID | Source | Class | What it supports | Accessed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| site | https://clinique-spontini.fr/ | clinic's own site | clinic self-presentation, physician names, RPPS numbers, treatment menu, address, phone, email | 31 August 2026 |
| rpps-sf | https://www.data.gouv.fr/api/1/datasets/r/fb55f15f-bd61-4402-b551-5… | official register | ANS RPPS savoir-faire extract — spécialité ordinale SM10 match for RPPS 10102261806 | 31 August 2026 |
| rpps-dipl | https://www.data.gouv.fr/api/1/datasets/r/41ae70ac-90c8-4c4e-8644-4… | official register | ANS RPPS diplôme/autorisation extract — medical diploma match for RPPS 10102261806 | 31 August 2026 |
| rpps-act | https://www.data.gouv.fr/api/1/datasets/r/fffda7e9-0ea2-4c35-bba0-4… | official register | ANS RPPS activity extract — Dr Edery listed at FINESS établissement juridique 750044257 | 31 August 2026 |
| finess | https://www.data.gouv.fr/api/1/datasets/r/98f3161f-79ff-4f16-8f6a-6… | official register | FINESS national establishment extract — facility record FINESS 750044265, category 630 | 31 August 2026 |
| legal | https://recherche-entreprises.api.gouv.fr/search?q=53801949800020&p… | official register | Recherche d'entreprises (DINUM) — SIREN 538019498 (Société Clinique Spontini), liquidateur on record, establishment closed 2024-09-02 | 31 August 2026 |
| legal2 | https://recherche-entreprises.api.gouv.fr/search?q=43947126900019&p… | official register | Recherche d'entreprises (DINUM) — SIREN 439471269 (Clinique Esthétique de Paris Spontini), a separate, earlier company at this address, recorded as ceased | 31 August 2026 |
| fronts | https://clinique-spontini.fr/ | clinic's own site | language fronts compared mechanically for M8 — fr: https://clinique-spontini.fr/ | en: https://clinique-spontini.fr/en/ | 21 September 2026 |
| legal-notice | https://clinique-spontini.fr/mentions-legales/ | clinic's own site | legal notice — publisher named without a legal form or a company number; the only company number on the page is the host provider | 20 September 2026 |
| rhinoplasty | https://clinique-spontini.fr/rhinoplastie-a-paris-16e-chirurgie-est… | clinic's own site | risks and complications, secondary revision, legal reflection period | 20 September 2026 |
| host-company | https://recherche-entreprises.api.gouv.fr/search?q=51090980700024&p… | official register | Recherche d'entreprises API — SIRET 51090980700024 returns the hosting provider O2SWITCH, activity 63.11Z, not a clinic operator | 20 September 2026 |
Change history
| Date | Change |
|---|---|
| 20 September 2026 | summary: "Aesthetic surgery and medicine clinic in Paris 16e, registered with the ARS as a standalone aesthetic-surgery facility (FINESS category 630) since 2012. The company that held that facility registration is recorded in liquidation in the national companies register; the clinic’s current site names two physicians and a different operating contact from the original registration." → "Aesthetic surgery and medicine clinic in Paris 16e. The national facility extract holds an ARS-authorised standalone aesthetic-surgery facility (FINESS category 630) under the legal-entity number the clinic publishes, recorded at a different street number in the same street. The company that held that facility registration is recorded in liquidation in the national companies register; the clinic’s legal notice names its publisher as a trading name without a legal form or a company registration number. The site names two physicians with their national registration numbers." (M4 re-scored 4 on the operator ruling: the summary no longer states the facility is registered at this address.) |
| 20 September 2026 | axes.M4: 5 → 4 (Operator ruling 2026-09-20: a name match with an address discrepancy is 4, not 5.) |
| 20 September 2026 | holds.H1.detail: "…Legal-entity axis (M5) held pending clarification of the clinic's current operator." → "…Clarification of the clinic's current operator is pending." (M5 was re-run against the companies register this pass and is no longer held (v1.2 loop pass 1).) |
| 20 September 2026 | axes.M9: "null/retry" → 3 (Re-run for real (v1.2 loop pass 1).) |
| 20 September 2026 | axes.M7: "null/retry" → 4 (Re-run for real (v1.2 loop pass 1).) |
| 20 September 2026 | axes.M6: "null/retry" → 4 (Re-run for real (v1.2 loop pass 1).) |
| 20 September 2026 | axes.M5: "null/retry" → 2 (Re-run for real (v1.2 loop pass 1).) |
| 17 September 2026 | axes.M8: null → 3 (Mechanical cross-locale comparison (methodology v1.1, item 9).) |
| 31 August 2026 | axes.M7: 3 → null (Citation re-check: quote not found at https://clinique-spontini.fr/ (quote not found); cell degraded to could-not-verify.) |
| 31 August 2026 | axes.M6: 5 → null (Citation re-check: quote not found at https://clinique-spontini.fr/ (quote not found); cell degraded to could-not-verify.) |
| 31 August 2026 | Initial collection. |
Correction or right of reply
Corrections are applied with a source link and logged publicly. A clinic statement without a source is published next to the data; the score does not change.